Not a single person reading this has ever successfully managed people. That’s because it can’t be done. Human beings resist being managed to the point of being impossible to manage.
People insist on being led. If you think managing and leading are one and the same then you may be a manager but you’re most certainly not a leader.
I’ve written about this before but since it’s been awhile here’s a refresher.
Managing and leading are two different things. You manage things. Things like a budget, buildings, inventory, property and the like. If it’s an “it” you can manage it. If “it” is not capable of expressing emotion go ahead and manage away.
But if you’re dealing with a flesh and blood person then attempting to manage them creates nearly every problem the typical manager complains about.
Leadership is about people and only people. When you attempt to manage people you risk treating them like things…at least they feel that way. That highlights one critical difference between managing and leading. Things don’t “feel” but people always do.
That makes leading far more challenging than managing. Dealing with our own emotions is tough enough, trying to make sense of other people’s emotions can be more than a little daunting. That’s likely why so many people in leadership positions don’t try. They try to manage their people instead.
Another reason that happens is that over 70% of the people in leadership positions have no formal leadership training. None. Zippo. Zero. They also have had no mentoring from a successful leader. They are put into a leadership position and then expected to fend for themselves. It’s almost as if people think leadership just happens.
Make no mistake about this absolute fact…leaders are not born, they are trained. The training can take on different forms but absent some type of training it is exceptionally rare for Authentic Leadership to emerge.
That makes for a difficult leadership experience, for both the leader and those they try to lead.
I wish I could tell you that every company that promotes someone to a leadership position also provides them with the training to succeed as a leader. Unfortunately very few actually do. So be aware that just as it is in much of life, if success as a leader is meant to be then it’s likely up to you to make it happen.
So find yourself a leadership development program to enroll in. Maybe even more important, find yourself a leadership mentor. Someone you trust and admire as a leader and ask them to show you how they do it.
If you’ve chosen the right person will be thrilled to invest their time to share their insights with you.
One last point. I don’t want anyone to think that I’m diminishing the importance of solid management within every organization. Poor management is in fact the cause of many business failures. If you’re a great manager then your impact on an organization can be substantial. You are vital to the success of any organization.
It’s important to understand however that being a great manager does not make you a great leader anymore than being a great leader makes you a great manager. Some people are blessed with both skillsets. Many are not and it’s incumbent upon you to know the difference.
5 thoughts on “Are You a Manager or a Leader?”
Reblogged this on The WWWFTP and commented:
If you want to succeed in business as an entrepreneur then one has to be able to switch between being a manager and a leader at will and know the difference and when to switch. A good leader must be flexible!
Great point, it before they can be flexible they need to understand that they need to be flexible.
Definitely in the Green and middle part.
Good for you, I’m sure anyone who follows you appreciates it.